“I just want to make sure that it’s the best material I’ve ever released”: King Diamond offers update on new solo album, says another single will “definitely” drop this year

King Diamond has offered an update on his first solo album since 2007.

In a new interview with Fistful Of Metal magazine, the Danish metal despot says that the follow-up to Bring Me Your Soul… Please is still being worked on, but that the next single from it will “definitely” come out in 2025. The new track will follow previous taster Spider Lilly, which landed in December.

The King also spills that his new album’s title has been changed from the one that was originally announced, The Institute.

“The original name that we had picked was The Institute. However, that has now changed to St Lucifer’s Hospital 1920, since the start of the US tour [from October to December 2024],” he reveals (via Blabbermouth).

The singer continues: “There very well may be a track on the album called The Institute. We were supposed to release the album this year, and in fact the album was supposed to be completely finished prior to the live shows, but I just want to make sure that it’s the best material I’ve ever released.”

The King then adds that there will be another song on the album entitled Lobotomy, the music video for which is about to be filmed. “[The single] will definitely be released later this year,” he says.

Other songs set to feature on St Lucifer’s Hospital 1920 include an “intro track” called Under The Surface, plus others called The Nun and Faceless.

Sign up below to get the latest from Metal Hammer, plus exclusive special offers, direct to your inbox!

“Andy [La Rocque, guitarist] has been working on at least five tracks, one of which has a monster chorus that we plan to record with a choir,” the King says. “The plan is that this album will be the first of a trilogy, and I already have all three album titles.”

King Diamond will hit the European festival circuit and play some headline shows across the continent from June to August. He also continues to front Mercyful Fate, who reunited in 2019 and have a new album of their own, their first since 9 in 1999, in the works.

Mercyful bassist Becky Baldwin said in an interview in January that the band were demoing their new material and that “instrumentally, it’s mostly there”.

“And so the next step is for King to work on it,” she added, “but King also needs to put out the King Diamond album this year, hopefully.”

King Diamond – Spider Lilly (Official Video) – YouTube King Diamond - Spider Lilly (Official Video) - YouTube

Watch On

“They played us The Things We Do For Love. We thought it was beige. They said, ‘We need a weird one, a slushy one and humour.’ I said, ‘We don’t work to order’”: How Godley and Creme quit 10cc and went to play with their Gizmotron instead

“They played us The Things We Do For Love. We thought it was beige. They said, ‘We need a weird one, a slushy one and humour.’ I said, ‘We don’t work to order’”: How Godley and Creme quit 10cc and went to play with their Gizmotron instead

Kevin Godley
(Image credit: Press)

Singer-songwriter, drummer and Gizmo co-inventor Kevin Godley met his soon-to-be creative partner Lol Creme at art school in the 60s. They played in numerous bands together, including Hotlegs, which eventually became 10cc. They left in 1977, became Godley & Creme, and were soon elevated from pop stars to in-demand pop video directors.

Godley tells Prog about the, ahem, consequences of the duo’s creative career, the recently released 11-CD set Parts Of The Process – The Complete Godley & Creme, and that time he was mistaken for Paper Lace’s drummer.


Art-school alumni, one-time prog pop star, songwriter, video and filmmaker, environmentalist: Kevin Godley has, for decades, confounded expectations in pursuit of what might be called his vision – though he’d probably baulk at the idea of being a visionary. At 79, he shows no signs of slowing down; he’s just completed work on an orchestral piece with American classical composer John Califra entitled America WTF? “It’s about the current political situation and divide in America,” he says. “It’s very dark.”

He’s also busy working on a musical, trying to finance two screenplays (both of which he had a hand in), and joining a video games company. “I’m not one of those people that will retire to the country and paint. I’m not that guy.”

We’re here to talk about the expansive new box set navigating Godley’s musical collaboration with former longtime writing partner Lol Creme. Parts Of The Process charts their musical arc post-10cc from the great triple disc/musical folly (argue among yourselves) Consequences – a concept piece that’s as much about divorce as it is meteorological disaster – to their final glimmering pop farewell, 1988’s Goodbye Blue Sky. However, our conversation touches on everything from his former band and writing with comedy giant Peter Cook to helping to pioneer the music video revolution and almost working with Bob Dylan.

Consequences reminds us of Zappa’s Jazz From Hell album. He was in thrall to making music with the Synclavier, while on Consequences you and Lol were intent on using the Gizmotron (Gizmo) device you invented. Would that be close to the truth?

Yes, we didn’t really get to use it very often in the context of the band. It just didn’t sit for whatever reason. We’d used it on one or two tracks. We kind of created this thing, conceived this thing and we thought, “Shit, what are we going to do with it?” I mean, we didn’t even know what it was capable of.

Sign up below to get the latest from Prog, plus exclusive special offers, direct to your inbox!

Not many musicians invent a piece of machinery in their downtime, let alone a Gizmo.

It was an actual piece of machinery, true. We’d always wanted to work with an orchestra in some capacity. But to actually do that you have to jump through a bunch of hoops, and they’re not cheap and they break for tea – stuff like that. There were Mellotrons around but we didn’t love them, and they kept breaking down.

On a good day the Gizmo sounded like an orchestra, and on a bad day it sounded like a chainsaw

We were looking at the guitar thinking, “This is a stringed instrument; why can it not be bowed in some way?” So, we sort of gaffer-taped Lol’s Stratocaster to the wall and. put an eraser on the end of an electric drill and held it against the guitar strings. A bit of a Leatherface vibe to it: it nearly sawed the thing in half! But for about four seconds there was a sound that was vaguely reminiscent of a violin. And we thought, “Ooh!”

So you made and marketed them.

Yep – John McConnell from the Manchester College of Science and Technology helped us develop the prototype. It was this bunch of wheels, sort of Da Vinci-ish, though not quite up there with the helicopter. It was John’s prototype that we made Consequences with. Then they were mass produced in the US by a company called Musitronics – but the timing was atrocious. It was the beginning of cheap synths, and it was very vulnerable to weather change and stuff like that. On a good day it sounded like an orchestra, and on a bad day it sounded like a chainsaw.

10cc – The Things We Do For Love – YouTube 10cc - The Things We Do For Love - YouTube

Watch On

In 1976 – post How Dare You! – you and Lol took the Gizmo into 10cc’s Strawberry Studios to start work on Consequences. Were you still in 10cc at this point?

Yeah; it was the end of the album cycle and tour, but we were still in the band. We had some downtime – three weeks in Strawberry, as I recall – and the potential of working the Gizmo got us excited again.

Weren’t you excited by 10cc any more?

The problem with being in any band is everything becomes rote after a while. You lose the spark; it’s like, ‘Oh God, there’s another tour coming, there’s another album coming. We’ve got to write another bunch of songs.’ We were looking for something fresh. Our attention span was very short.

You were smoking your own body weight in dope and recording through the night. What was your mindset like at the time?

The label thought, ’We better get a responsible adult in to tame them.’ And the responsible adult was Peter Cook!

I suppose it was like – not a vanity project exactly, but something to test the capabilities of what we’d done. But there was no master plan. The first week or so was, “Let’s plug it in and see what comes out,” because we’d never really used it other than on Old Wild Men [from Sheet Music]. At one point, we created a tape loop – Phil Manzanera’s idea, as I recall. We put a bump in the tape and it sounded like a soprano opera singer. That was a revelation. But mainly, it was fun again. Then, as you know, it turned into a monster.

When did you both decide that you’d had enough of 10cc?

It wasn’t really one moment. There were a few meetings had because the label had been in touch. “It’s time for you to make a new album, boys.” Eric Stewart and Graham Gouldman had started writing songs for it. And we just didn’t have a taste for it. We were too into this.

They played us something – it might have been The Things We Do For Love – and we just thought it was beige. We’d had this pre-production meeting about the next album, and it went something like, “We need one of your long, weird ones, a slushy one, and we need some humour.” I was, like, “Hang on a minute – we don’t work to order.”

5 O’Clock In The Morning – YouTube 5 O'Clock In The Morning - YouTube

Watch On

Prior to that, it was all about spending a certain amount of time in the studio and doing what we were capable of doing. We’d been relatively successful by going in the opposite direction. That’s what I enjoyed more than anything else. It was becoming a day job: we were taking care of business, but we didn’t take care of each other. We might have gone away and decided to come back if we’d had the time to stretch out and do what we wanted for a while, but that wasn’t allowed to happen. Four blokes. Four albums. Four years. That was it.”

Going back to Consequences, you and Lol decamped to the residential Manor Studios for three months, with Peter Cook in tow to continue with the recording sessions. Of all the people…

I don’t think he was there for the full three, but we had a lot of fun. I have this suspicion that by then the record label was thinking, “What the hell are these two idiots up to? We’ve agreed to release a record, but they’re spending more than the value of our country on this project. So, we better get a responsible adult in to tame them.” And the responsible adult they chose was Peter Cook!

They didn’t know there was a live mic open. We heard: ’What the fuck was that?’ ’No fucking clue. Are we going to sell that?’

It was a fascinating time. There were maybe two or three hours in the day where we were in sync. We worked at night and Peter, obviously, worked in the day. His concept was the divorced couple in the story; we’d provide the music and react to what the other was doing, but we’d rise at lunchtime, and we’d have a few hours together before Peter would start drinking. We were enjoying every second – that’s not to say we had a clue about what we were doing.

And there was no outside influence or producer to help guide you, tap on the studio glass and ask what the hell you were doing?

We were those producers! I remember there was an instance very early on when we were still at Strawberry. The managers of 10cc at the time came to hear what we were up to, so we played them the first 15 minutes that we had. We left them to it and they were saying all the right things – “Wow, extraordinary, amazing!”

Godley & Creme – An Englishman In New York – YouTube Godley & Creme - An Englishman In New York - YouTube

Watch On

We went out to have a cigarette, and they carried on talking in the studio, but what they didn’t know was that there was a live mic open. And we heard: “What the fuck was that?” “No fucking clue. Are we going to sell that?” The complete opposite reaction – but very managerial!

Among the dialogue and storytelling tangents, there are songs like Five O’ Clock In The Morning, which would have fitted perfectly on any of the first four 10cc records.

It was part of who we were; it’s in our DNA, so when we decided to write some actual songs, it sounded like us.

That album and a lot of your 10cc work is very visual. Is that a part of how you’re built too?

I think everything we ever wrote was visual. The only tools we had were audio tools; we didn’t mix with film people. We didn’t have a way into film, but we were art school trained. So there was always something bubbling underneath, but we did it in sound. I think we even called Consequences an “ear movie” at the time.

We’d become audio hermits. We weren’t aware of what was stirring: punk rock, the Sex Pistols, the polar opposite of what we were doing

I remember going outside to record windscreen wipers on the car in the rain – I forget for which song, but we were dedicated to getting it right. I’m in my car and the windscreen wipers were going, and it’s pissing rain and we had this mic outside. And there’s the guy on the pavement just looking at me, and it’s night time, and eventually he plucks up the courage and taps on my window. I wind it down and he leans in and goes: “Excuse me, are you the drummer from Paper Lace?” We got that on tape!

Lol says you were personally heartbroken when the album died a commercial death. Is heartbroken too big a word?

No – I was, because something happened to me maybe about three-quarters of the way through making it. I was very aware that we’d become audio hermits. We weren’t remotely aware of the outside world, what was stirring: punk rock, the Sex Pistols, the exact polar opposite of what we were doing. And when things like that happen, you must be aware of them. You can’t just keep going blindly and deathly forward, because it doesn’t really make sense.

I learned a lesson from that, but we were too far into it to start from scratch – forget about it. Then we heard they were going to release it as a three-album box set, selling for the extortionate amount of £12 quid in 1977 [approximately £70 today]. It was so ill-conceived; it did us a huge amount of damage. It fucked us up. We both put a huge amount of work into it, and no one liked it. No one understood it , and that ain’t going to help a career. It got slated in the press. We were the audio version of the movie Heaven’s Gate.

Did it really cost a million pounds in today’s money?

I don’t know how much it cost. It couldn’t have been cheap. Everyone was in and there was no way out. Peter Cook – even just that cost them a pretty penny. That’s for damn sure.

Remarkably, a mere two years later, the label fronted you cash again for something that couldn’t be quantified at the time: a music video.

I know; we weren’t a touring band. We had a single coming out, we were always a bit of an anomaly for the label. They didn’t quite know what to do with us, particularly after Consequences. The album was Freeze Frame and the lead single was Englishman In New York, and we thought the only way to get seen or heard was to do a short film or something. So we came up with a storyboard and the label loved it. We didn’t know there was going to be such a thing as the video industry or indeed videos. Nobody did then.

They got us a director called Derek Burbidge [The Police, AC/DC] and his job was to make our vision, such as it was, come to life – which he did, admirably, and during that one day of shooting and the subsequent day of editing, a huge light bulb switched on above our heads. We thought, “Fuck, this is brilliant – we could do this!” I even liked being out front in my red shirt and my swish suit, Mr Cool. When I looked at myself I thought, “Fuck off!” but at least I was trying.

Then in 1980, Steve Strange and Visage approached you about making something for them for their Fade To Grey single.

Yeah, our albums were slowly ticking over, but we still weren’t touring; we weren’t doing anything. They wanted a video because they couldn’t get on Top Of The Pops or Whistle Test, so they made a film as a stopgap. People would play the film and liked what they were seeing, but there was no infrastructure in place; no video commissioners.

It was all word-of-mouth, musician to musician – a trust thing. So we were lucky. We were at the beginning of something; we’d never been in that place before. We filmed it, helped do the edit, learning all the time. Then we began to be the go-to people for a while. We had this reputation. And we got to do some really interesting things.

You must have had so much creative energy at that point. You did more than 50 music videos in the 80s for The Police, Duran Duran, George Harrison Lou Reed and others, and yet you were still making music.

Orson Welles was asked about how he’d made Citizen Kane. He said one of the most important ingredients was ignorance

I remember us putting out Under Your Thumb [from 1981’s Ismism], and we didn’t have any hope for it at all as a single. And we were shooting a video for Toyah Willcox [Thunder In The Mountains] on an airfield somewhere. A production guy came running up and said the single had just gone in the top 50. I was like, “Hang on a minute – how do we deploy the two things that we do?” But it was the same stuff. It just came out of two different taps. We turn this one on when we’re doing film. We turn this one on when we’re doing audio. It was just a natural thing, and those two things had somehow matured together.

You ended your creative partnership with Lol after arguably one of the best albums of your career, 1988’s Goodbye Blue Sky – which earned you an unlikely fan.

Dave Stewart got my wife and I in to see Bob Dylan at Hammersmith Apollo and we got to stand backstage and watch him. At the end of part one, after wowing everyone with Maggie’s Farm or something, he walked straight up to me and said, “You still making videos? Want to make one for me?” And then walked off. We met him at a hotel a few days later and he said, “You did a video where people were going through each other. Coming forward and going back,” and I couldn’t remember what he was talking about. It was A Little Piece of Heaven, which must have been on MTV all of two times – and he’d seen it! We never got to work together, but what a moment.

Godley & Creme – Golden Boy – YouTube Godley & Creme - Golden Boy - YouTube

Watch On

Did Cry – the haunting video and the equally haunting song – feel like the culmination of both of your creative taps?

Yes. People still want to talk about that video to me; it was a real moment in time. Elbow got me to recreate it for their Gentle Storm single – you know the crossfading faces? That was plan B; that was never meant to be the video. We wanted Torvill and Dean to skate to it, but they couldn’t do it when we needed them. We had to come up with something else sharpish, and that was what we came up with. Even after we’d shot it, we weren’t sure what we were going to do with it until we got into the edit suite. Then we started dissolving between faces and that’s when the penny dropped, and it got really interesting.

What’s the best 10cc album, and why is it Sheet Music?

Because we were a little bit more knowledgeable. It’s 1974; it’s our second album, so we’re a little bit more sophisticated – but we didn’t know it all then. Which from that point on we kind of did. We kind of knew who our audience was and what they might want.

Something that Orson Welles once said when he was asked about how he’d made Citizen Kane. He said one of the most important ingredients was ignorance: “I didn’t know how to do things, so I figured that anything I thought of would be possible.” Which he made happen. Not only by doing things like that, but thinking like that. That’s how you move a medium and the technology that drives it forward. If it’s too easy and too obvious, what’s the point?

“It would be ridiculous to try to rock there.” Watch the trailer for Queens of the Stone Age’s Alive in the Catacombs film, documenting a unique performance underneath Paris “surrounded by several million dead people”

“It would be ridiculous to try to rock there.” Watch the trailer for Queens of the Stone Age’s Alive in the Catacombs film, documenting a unique performance underneath Paris “surrounded by several million dead people”

QOTSA Alive In The Catacombs
(Image credit:  Andreas Neumann)

Queens of the Stone Age have shared a trailer for Alive in the Catacombs, a film documenting their performance in the world-famous Catacombs of Paris, the final resting place for millions of French citizens, interred in the 1700s.

The Los Angeles band’s performance in the eerie tunnels beneath the French capital represented the fulfilment of a long-held dream for QOTSA frontman Josh Homme, who first visited the extraordinary location almost 20 years ago. No band had ever before been granted permission to play in the Catacombs, which made the group’s stripped-back set, augmented by a three-piece string section, genuinely historic.

A press statement for the film, which will be available to view from June 5, reads: “Every aesthetic decision, every choice of song, every configuration of instruments… absolutely everything was planned and played with deference to the Catacombs- from the acoustics and ambient sounds – dripping water, echoes and natural resonance – to the darkly atmospheric lighting tones that enhance the music. Far from the sound-insulated confines of the studio or the comfort of onstage monitors, Alive in the Catacombs sees the band not only rise to this challenge, but embrace it.”

Josh Homme says, “We’re so stripped down because that place is so stripped down, which makes the music so stripped down, which makes the words so stripped down… It would be ridiculous to try to rock there. All those decisions were made by that space. That space dictates everything, it’s in charge. You do what you’re told when you’re in there.”

He adds, “If you’re ever going to be haunted, surrounded by several million dead people is the place. I’ve never felt so welcome in my life.”

Queens of the Stone Age – Alive in the Catacombs (Official Trailer) – YouTube Queens of the Stone Age - Alive in the Catacombs (Official Trailer) - YouTube

Watch On


Queens of the Stone Age will play their first shows since summer 2024 next month.

Their US mini-tour kicks off with a pair of shows at the MGM Music Hall at Fenway in Boston, on June 10 and 11. The band will travel to Europe to play shows in July and August, including an August 20 Dublin gig at the Irish Museum of Modern Art, Royal Hospital Kilmainham, and a headline performance at the Rock N Roll Circus at Sheffield’s Don Valley Bowl on August 27.

The latest news, features and interviews direct to your inbox, from the global home of alternative music.

Cancelling shows last summer, the band released a statement saying, “QOTSA regret to announce the cancellation and/or postponement of all remaining 2024 shows. Josh has been given no choice but to prioritize his health and to receive essential medical care throughout the remainder of the year. Josh and the QOTSA family are so thankful for your support and the time we were able to spend together over the last year. Hope to see you all again in 2025.”

A music writer since 1993, formerly Editor of Kerrang! and Planet Rock magazine (RIP), Paul Brannigan is a Contributing Editor to Louder. Having previously written books on Lemmy, Dave Grohl (the Sunday Times best-seller This Is A Call) and Metallica (Birth School Metallica Death, co-authored with Ian Winwood), his Eddie Van Halen biography (Eruption in the UK, Unchained in the US) emerged in 2021. He has written for Rolling Stone, Mojo and Q, hung out with Fugazi at Dischord House, flown on Ozzy Osbourne’s private jet, played Angus Young’s Gibson SG, and interviewed everyone from Aerosmith and Beastie Boys to Young Gods and ZZ Top. Born in the North of Ireland, Brannigan lives in North London and supports The Arsenal.

Public Service Broadcasting to perform The Last Flight at the Barbican in November

Public Service Broadcasting have announced two special live performances of their most recent album, last year’s acclaimed The Last Flight, with the London Contemporary Orchestra, at London’s Barbican Theatre in November.

The band and the 20-piece string section from the orchestra will perform two shows on November 1, at 3pm and at 8pm.

The Last Flight saw the arch conceptualists looking at the final journey of aviator Amelia Earhart, the first woman to fly solo across the Atlantic and Pacific oceans, who went missing in her new Lockheed Electra plane on the ill-fated 1937 journey.

Public Service Broadcasting are no strangers to unique live events. They performed a “specially commissioned new arrangement” of 2015’s The Race For Space on July 25, 2019 in a late-night prom that aired on BBC television and in 2022 they played a specially commissioned, album-length piece for Prom 58 called This New Noise, with the BBC Symphony Orchestra at the Royal Albert Hall in London to celebrate 100 years of the BBC.

Tickets go on general sale on Friday May 16 at 10am, with artist and members presale Wednesday May 14 at 10am.

Get tickets.

Sign up below to get the latest from Prog, plus exclusive special offers, direct to your inbox!

Why Bad Company Was Different Than Free

Bad Company was different. Although Paul Rodgers and Simon Kirke had a difficult journey with their previous band, Free, it was one they felt they wouldn’t repeat with their new group.

“I think that the key person at that time was Mick Ralphs, because obviously I’d worked with Paul for five years,” Kirke tells the UCR Podcast in a new interview you can listen to below. “Our first couple of years were a slog, but we sort of climbed the mountain. We knew each other well and we always got on. We were like the hand in glove, it fit very well. But Mick, even though we had known him through Mott the Hoople and they were on Island Records…we’d met each other a few times, but I’d never worked with him.”

Humor, the great connector in many creative partnerships, was quick to lend a hand. “He is one of the funniest guys,” the drummer confirms. “He’s so light-hearted and he played great guitar. I’d been used to working with Paul Kossoff, who was a genius, but he was a tortured genius. He fell victim to drug addiction pretty quickly. The last couple of years with Kos were hard. So, along comes this guy who has these great songs. He plays really good lead guitar and is funny as hell. Me and Paul bonded with him pretty much out of the gate. That was the difference between Free and Bad Company. It was light-hearted and a liberation, in a way.”

Bassist Boz Burrell was the final piece of the puzzle, and as Kirke remembers, that took some doing, because of his ties to King Crimson, but the issue might surprise you. “He was at the bottom of the 16-member list of [potential] bassists, because we didn’t like King Crimson,” he explains. “That wasn’t our cup of tea at all — although I do love [the band name].” Ultimately and thankfully, it worked out. “Boz was the very last bass player to be auditioned and he was another light-hearted and easygoing guy. It was just a wonderful fit.”

The Birth of ‘Bad Company’

The band’s 1974 self-titled debut album features eight tracks, and they are regarded as classics and fan favorites today, more than 50 years later. Kirke helped Rodgers pen the iconic song that ended up starting the album’s second side. “Bad Company” is an example of the atmospheric and very visual songs that the English rock group would become known for. “I remember going down to Paul’s cottage down in Surrey, just south of London, and I heard this piano,” he says now. “I thought he had maybe an electric piano, but no, it was a grand piano that he had somehow shoehorned into his little cottage, and he was playing this riff.”

READ MORE: Top 10 Bad Company Songs

“For anyone out there who is musically minded, particularly keyboardists or pianists, it’s written in E flat minor, which is all of the black notes. [Kirke demonstrates the keyboard pattern] It’s kind of a haunting riff,” the drummer continues. “He said, ‘What do you think of this? ‘Company, always on the run.’ It came from all of the bounty hunters in the 1800s, the long plains drifters, who used to chase bandits — and we were the bandits, Bad Company. I just thought it was a wonderful vibe and the fact that it was done in this haunting way [was what made it work]. We’ve tried ‘Bad Company’ in other keys since and it just didn’t work. [After he shared the initial lyric with me], I said, ‘How about, ‘Destiny, is the rising sun,’ and it just kind of snowballed from there. I believe we finished it in about 20 minutes.”

Listen to Bad Company’s ‘Bad Company’

What’s Coming Up For Bad Company?

The rock legends will be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in November. They received their first nomination earlier this year after becoming eligible in 2000. Kirke admits it will be a poignant night in light of Ralphs’ health issues. “I hope I don’t get too emotional when I mention Mick, because we’re going to give him the big shout,” he said. “I spoke with him briefly [after the induction news was announced]. He can’t talk very well because he had a stroke. I just hope I can hold it together without sort of breaking down.”

Later this year, Bad Company will also be honored with a tribute album. Can’t Get Enough: A Tribute to Bad Company is set to arrive this fall. Fans got a preview of the upcoming set from the Struts, who shared their take on the group’s legendary single “Rock & Roll Fantasy” on a 7″ vinyl single for Record Store Day. Kirke tells UCR that he and Rodgers plan to collaborate with Def Leppard’s Joe Elliott, a longtime fan, on a new version of “Seagull.”

Listen to Bad Company’s Simon Kirke on the ‘UCR Podcast’

19 Rock Guitars That Were Stolen or Lost (and Sometimes Found)

Some of these are still out there somewhere.

Gallery Credit: Allison Rapp

15 Rock Bands That Don’t Deserve All the Hate They Get

15 Rock Bands That Don’t Deserve All the Hate They Get

Baseball Hall of Famer Reggie Jackson once famously said, “Fans don’t boo nobodies.” It’s the kind of quote printed on motivational materials and paraphrased in energy drink commercials, but its message is true. Fans reserve their strongest hate for the biggest names, which applies to music as easily as sports.

Each rock act — no matter how revered — has at some point been the target of unfair contempt. The Beatles have been called overrated. Bob Dylan’s voice has been mocked. Someone, somewhere, has even described Jimi Hendrix’s guitar playing as “just average.” Such criticisms are just the price for fame, yet some bands have received far more scorn than their peers.

Below, we’ve highlighted 15 Rock Bands That Don’t Deserve All the Hate They Get. In every case, these artists are unquestioned successes – Grammy winners, Rock & Roll Hall of Famers, multiplatinum millionaires and legends of their time. Still, for various reasons, they’ve also been the target of vitriol.

READ MORE: 10 Singers Who Left Bands Before They Got Famous

We’ve done our best to analyze the respective sources of this hate. For some, it came down to a band’s decision to head in a new musical direction. For others, resentment grew after a prominent lineup change. Then there’s the classic cliche of selling out, a claim fans often throw at acts when they achieve massive mainstream popularity.

Whatever silly reasons exist, we say enough is enough. These acts have taken the heat for too long, and it’s time to give them a break.

15 Bands That Don’t Deserve All the Hate They Get

More From Ultimate Classic Rock

Complete List Of The Pretty Reckless Songs From A to Z

Complete List Of The Pretty Reckless Songs From A to Z

Feature Photo: Craig Noce, CC BY 3.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

The Pretty Reckless formed in New York City in 2009, fronted by lead vocalist and rhythm guitarist Taylor Momsen, who transitioned from a successful acting career to pursue her passion for music. Momsen, known for her roles in How the Grinch Stole Christmas and Gossip Girl, founded the group alongside guitarist Ben Phillips, bassist Mark Damon, and drummer Jamie Perkins. The band quickly began shaping their identity around a hard rock and post-grunge sound, blending brooding themes with heavy instrumentation. Their first public performances included opening slots on the Warped Tour and headline shows in the U.K., paving the way for their debut release.

Their first studio album, Light Me Up, dropped in August 2010 and introduced audiences to their dark-edged, riff-heavy style. Anchored by singles like “Make Me Wanna Die,” “Miss Nothing,” and “Just Tonight,” the album built a strong international following, particularly in the United Kingdom, where it debuted at number six. The band followed with the Hit Me Like a Man EP in 2012, keeping momentum alive while writing new material. By this point, The Pretty Reckless had firmly established their gritty aesthetic and earned a reputation for raw, high-energy performances.

In March 2014, the band released their second studio album, Going to Hell, which marked a commercial breakthrough in the U.S. and abroad. Singles “Heaven Knows,” “Messed Up World,” and “Follow Me Down” all reached number one on the U.S. Mainstream Rock chart, a rare feat for a female-fronted rock band. The album debuted at number five on the Billboard 200, and the band supported the release with extensive touring, including headline runs and major festival appearances. Going to Hell cemented their presence on modern rock radio and broadened their fan base across North America and Europe.

The momentum continued with the release of their third album, Who You Selling For, in October 2016 via Razor & Tie. The album showcased a broader sonic palette, incorporating blues-rock and soul influences. The lead single “Take Me Down” gave the band their fourth number one on the Mainstream Rock chart, reinforcing their streak of radio dominance. Critics praised the record for its ambition and Momsen’s evolving vocal performance. Tours with Soundgarden and other major acts followed, underscoring the band’s growing stature in the hard rock circuit.

Tragedy struck in 2017 when Chris Cornell, with whom the band had been touring, died by suicide. That event, along with the death of longtime producer Kato Khandwala in a motorcycle accident in 2018, profoundly affected the band. They took time off to regroup and channel their grief into music, eventually returning with Death by Rock and Roll, released in February 2021. The title track earned their fifth number one on the U.S. Mainstream Rock chart, followed by two more chart-topping singles: “And So It Went” featuring Tom Morello, and “Only Love Can Save Me Now,” featuring members of Soundgarden. With those hits, The Pretty Reckless became the first female-fronted band to score seven number one singles on that chart.

Throughout their career, the band has earned accolades not only for their commercial success but also for Momsen’s unique role as a female leader in a male-dominated genre. They’ve been nominated for and won multiple awards, including iHeartRadio Music Awards and Loudwire Music Awards. Their uncompromising attitude, commanding live shows, and strong visual identity have made them a fixture in modern rock.

Outside of music, Momsen has continued to draw attention for her fashion influence, often collaborating with major style publications and brands. She’s also been candid about the mental health struggles that shaped the band’s songwriting, using her platform to discuss grief, identity, and resilience. The Pretty Reckless continues to tour and record, maintaining their position as one of the most consistently successful hard rock acts of the 2010s and 2020s.

Complete List Of The Pretty Reckless Songs From A to Z

  1. AbsolutionGoing to Hell – 2014
  2. Already DeadWho You Selling For – 2016
  3. And So It Went (featuring Tom Morello)Death by Rock and Roll – 2021
  4. Back to the River (featuring Warren Haynes)Who You Selling For – 2016
  5. Bedroom WindowWho You Selling For – 2016
  6. Blame MeGoing to Hell – 2014
  7. BroomsticksDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  8. BurnGoing to Hell – 2014
  9. Cold BloodedHit Me Like a Man EP – 2012
  10. Death by Rock and RollDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  11. Dear SisterGoing to Hell – 2014
  12. Everybody Wants Something from Me (Demo)Light Me Up – 2010
  13. Factory GirlLight Me Up – 2010
  14. Far from NeverLight Me Up – 2010
  15. Far from Never (Demo)Light Me Up – 2010
  16. Follow Me DownGoing to Hell – 2014
  17. Fucked Up WorldGoing to Hell – 2014
  18. Going to HellGoing to Hell – 2014
  19. Going to Hell (Live Acoustic)Going to Hell – 2014
  20. Going to Hell (Radio Edit)Going to Hell – 2014
  21. Goin’ DownLight Me Up/The Pretty Reckless EP – 2010
  22. Got So HighDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  23. Harley DarlingDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  24. Heaven KnowsGoing to Hell – 2014
  25. Hit Me Like a ManHit Me Like a Man EP – 2012
  26. House on a HillGoing to Hell – 2014
  27. Just TonightLight Me Up – 2010
  28. Kill MeGoing to Hell – 2014
  29. Light Me UpLight Me Up – 2010
  30. Living in the StormWho You Selling For – 2016
  31. Mad LoveWho You Selling For – 2016
  32. Make Me Wanna DieLight Me Up/The Pretty Reckless EP – 2010
  33. Make Me Wanna Die (Acoustic Version)Light Me Up – 2010
  34. Make Me Wanna Die (Live in London)Hit Me Like a Man EP – 2012
  35. Messed Up World (F’d Up World)Going to Hell – 2014
  36. Miss NothingLight Me Up – 2010
  37. My BonesDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  38. My MedicineLight Me Up/The Pretty Reckless EP – 2010
  39. Nothing Left to LoseLight Me Up – 2010
  40. Oh My GodWho You Selling For – 2016
  41. Only Love Can Save Me Now (featuring Kim Thayil and Matt Cameron)Death by Rock and Roll – 2021
  42. Only YouGoing to Hell – 2014
  43. PrisonerWho You Selling For – 2016
  44. Rock and Roll HeavenDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  45. Since You’re GoneLight Me Up – 2010
  46. Since You’re Gone (Live in London)Hit Me Like a Man EP – 2012
  47. Standing at the WallDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  48. Sweet ThingsGoing to Hell – 2014
  49. Sweet Things (Acoustic)Going to Hell – 2014
  50. Take Me DownWho You Selling For – 2016
  51. The Devil’s BackWho You Selling For – 2016
  52. The Devil’s Back (Demo Version)Who You Selling For – 2016
  53. The Walls Are Closing In / HangmanWho You Selling For – 2016
  54. Turning GoldDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  55. Under the WaterHit Me Like a Man EP – 2012
  56. Waiting for a FriendGoing to Hell – 2014
  57. Who You Selling ForWho You Selling For – 2016
  58. Why’d You Bring a Shotgun to the PartyGoing to Hell – 2014
  59. Wild CityWho You Selling For – 2016
  60. Witches BurnDeath by Rock and Roll – 2021
  61. YouLight Me Up – 2010
  62. ZombieLight Me Up/The Pretty Reckless EP – 2010
  63. 25Death by Rock and Roll – 2021

Albums

The Pretty Reckless EP (2010): 4 songs (all appear on Light Me Up)

Light Me Up (2010): 15 songs

Hit Me Like a Man EP (2012): 5 songs (including 2 live versions of previously released songs)

Going to Hell (2014): 18 songs

Who You Selling For (2016): 13 songs

Death by Rock and Roll (2021): 12 songs

Check out our fantastic and entertaining The Pretty Reckless articles, detailing in-depth the band’s albums, songs, band members, and more…all on ClassicRockHistory.com

Complete List Of The Pretty Reckless Albums And Discography

Top 10 The Pretty Reckless Songs

Read More: Artists’ Interviews Directory At ClassicRockHistory.com

Read More: Classic Rock Bands List And Directory

Complete List Of The Pretty Reckless Songs From A to Z article published on ClassicRockHistory.com© 2025

DMCA.com Protection Status

About The Author

Brian Kachejian

More from this Author

Brian Kachejian was born in Manhattan and raised in the Bronx. He is the founder and Editor in Chief of ClassicRockHistory.com. He has spent thirty years in the music business often working with many of the people who have appeared on this site. Brian Kachejian also holds B.A. and M.A. degrees from Stony Brook University along with New York State Public School Education Certifications in Music and Social Studies. Brian Kachejian is also an active member of the New York Press.

“I got this call from Lars Ulrich…”: Alice In Chains’ Jerry Cantrell reveals how he ended up on the soundtrack to horror blockbuster Sinners

Alice In Chains guitarist/vocalist Jerry Cantrell has explained how he ended up appearing on the soundtrack to horror blockbuster Sinners.

The 59-year-old, who co-founded Alice In Chains in 1987, lends his voice to the track In Moonlight, which was released on April 18 as part of an official collection of songs from and inspired by the vampire film.

Talking exclusively to Metal Hammer, Cantrell reveals that he was put in contact with Sinners composer Ludwig Göransson (Oppenheimer, Black Panther, etc.) by Metallica drummer Lars Ulrich. Ulrich is credited as a performer on the song Bury That Guitar from the film’s score.

“I got this call from Lars, who’d done drums with Ludwig Göransson as part of it,” Cantrell tells us. “He explained that Ludwig and the director Ryan Coogler wanted to talk to me about taking a piece of the score and writing a song out of it. So he put it together and we pounded out In Moonlight, which was great, man, and the movie is so well-made.”

One of Sinners’ key themes is the appropriation of Black music and culture via colonialism. In an interview with The Breakfast Club earlier this year, writer/director Ryan Coogler (Creed, Black Panther) revealed that the grunge genre, pioneered by Alice In Chains and other Seattle rock bands, was a major influence on the film.

“I started listening to it, bro, and I was like, ‘This shit is like what my uncle used to play’: the blues,” he said. “I’m listening to it, I’m listening to the guitar riffs and what they’re talking about and the passion they’re singing with, and I’m like, ‘That’s odd.’ I dug into the research, man, and that’s exactly what it is: it’s just blues music sung by white people.”

Sinners was made on a production budget of $90 million and is currently nearing a $300 million global box office take. Over the weekend, it reached the $200 million domestic box office mark, becoming the first original film to earn that much in North America since Pixar’s Coco in 2017.

Sign up below to get the latest from Metal Hammer, plus exclusive special offers, direct to your inbox!

The film has also been met with critical acclaim, boasting a 97 percent approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes at time of publication.

Cantrell released his new solo album, I Want Blood, in October. He’ll start a solo tour of Europe on May 31 and will stop at Download festival in the UK on June 15, followed by a headlining London show on June 17. See the full list of dates via the guitarist’s website.

Alice In Chains recently had to cancel a North American tour due to drummer Sean Kinney suffering a “non-life-threatening medical emergency”. The scrapped run included headline performances and a slot at the Sonic Temple festival in Columbus, Ohio.

The band are booked to appear at Black Sabbath’s farewell show at Villa Park, Birmingham, on July 5.

Jerry Cantrell, Ludwig Göransson – In Moonlight | Sinners (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) – YouTube Jerry Cantrell, Ludwig Göransson - In Moonlight | Sinners (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) - YouTube

Watch On

“It’s not a political statement, it is a human reaction to a horrific and unimaginable situation.” Watch The Murder Capital perform a free acoustic gig in a Cologne park after two German gigs are cancelled over Palestinian flag display

“It’s not a political statement, it is a human reaction to a horrific and unimaginable situation.” Watch The Murder Capital perform a free acoustic gig in a Cologne park after two German gigs are cancelled over Palestinian flag display

The Murder Capital
(Image credit: Mr Chunks YouTube)

The Murder Capital played a free acoustic gig in Cologne last night, May 11, after their scheduled gig at the city’s Gebäude 9 venue was cancelled due to the club refusing to let the Dublin band perform with a Palestinian flag onstage.

The Irish band also had their gig at Berlin’s Club Gretchen cancelled on Saturday, May 11, for the same reason.

The Murder Capital’s frontman James McGovern explained the situation to fans in Cologne yesterday afternoon.

“We arrived into Cologne this morning hoping that what happened in Berlin yesterday would be an isolated incident,” he posted on X. “But tonight’s venue, Gebäude 9, has also told us that we cannot have the Palestinian flag on our stage.

“We’ve tried everything we can to find another venue for tonight’s show, but it’s been impossible. So we’ll be putting on an acoustic show outdoors in a park somewhere this evening.”

“Us having a flag on our stage at a rock show is not a political statement, it is a human reaction to a horrific and unimaginable situation.”


Last year, the band donated all profits from their vinyl single Love Of Country to Medical Aid for Palestine.

In a statement at the time, McGovern said: “We are releasing a 7” record of Love Of Country, with 100 per cent of the proceeds going to Medical Aid for Palestine. In the face of, and beyond such clear acts of evil, it is more vital than ever to cherish the richness of our diverse communities and the power of human connection. We must stand firm against the rise of nationalist ideologies and speak up for those whose worlds are being torn apart by hatred and violence.”

The latest news, features and interviews direct to your inbox, from the global home of alternative music.

Watch the band play Love of Country and Swallow in Cologne below:


Irish artists have been among the most vocal in regards to the ongoing conflict in Gaza.

Fontaines DC, Kneecap, Lankum, CMAT and others have regularly expressed their support for the Palestinian people, and raised funds for Medical Aid for Palestine via gigs and merchandise sales, while all 12 Irish artists invited to play official showcases at the SXSW music festival in Texas last year – including Sprints, NewDad and Gurriers, cancelled their gigs, after it was revealed that the US army and defence contractors which supply weapons to Israel are among its sponsors.

In the wake of the protest, SXSW announced that it was dropping the US Army and weapons manufacturers as sponsors for 2025.

Fontaines D.C. win the Album Award for ‘Romance’ – YouTube Fontaines D.C. win the Album Award for 'Romance' - YouTube

Watch On

A music writer since 1993, formerly Editor of Kerrang! and Planet Rock magazine (RIP), Paul Brannigan is a Contributing Editor to Louder. Having previously written books on Lemmy, Dave Grohl (the Sunday Times best-seller This Is A Call) and Metallica (Birth School Metallica Death, co-authored with Ian Winwood), his Eddie Van Halen biography (Eruption in the UK, Unchained in the US) emerged in 2021. He has written for Rolling Stone, Mojo and Q, hung out with Fugazi at Dischord House, flown on Ozzy Osbourne’s private jet, played Angus Young’s Gibson SG, and interviewed everyone from Aerosmith and Beastie Boys to Young Gods and ZZ Top. Born in the North of Ireland, Brannigan lives in North London and supports The Arsenal.

“The whole prog movement is about fairies and elves and we’re proud of that. But there are no fairies and elves on this album”: How prog metal icons Dream Theater went full nerd-mode with epic concept album The Astonishing

“The whole prog movement is about fairies and elves and we’re proud of that. But there are no fairies and elves on this album”: How prog metal icons Dream Theater went full nerd-mode with epic concept album The Astonishing

Dream Theater posing for a photograph in 2016
(Image credit: Jimmy Fontaine/Press)

At two hours and 34 tracks, prog metal icons Dream Theater’s 2016 album The Astonishing was ambitious even by their standards. Metal Hammer sat down with the band as the album was released to talk concepts, sci-fi and going full nerd.

A divider for Metal Hammer

Preposterous. There is no other word for it. Even within heavy metal, where bombast, self-indulgence and voyages through the surreal and hyperreal are cherished tenets, the new Dream Theater album stands out like a kaleidoscopic monolith floating majestically in an ocean of grey slurry. More than two hours long, and underpinned by an elaborate story set 300 years into some monstrous dystopian future, The Astonishing fully lives up to its name. In fact, Dream Theater may have lost their minds completely…

“Ha ha! Yeah, like, ‘What the hell is wrong with you guys?’” grins guitarist John Petrucci, mastermind of The Astonishing’s concept and narrative, as he reclines on a sofa at their label’s London office, along with keyboard maestro Jordan Rudess and vocalist James LaBrie. “We often ask ourselves that question! As far as timing goes, it definitely felt right for all of us to do a concept album again. The last one we did was [1999’s] Scenes From A Memory. In order to do it right, we really wanted to do it to the fullest extent – have a full story, developed characters and not only write an album, but write a show that we can present. And it didn’t start small [and grow], it started off with the full, grand idea! Ha ha ha! That’s just the way we work. Nothing was haphazard at all. It was very thought-out and very detailed.”

“We’re still a rock band, though!” Jordan interjects with a wry smile. “It’s a little uncommon for every detail to be thought out in a rock band, but still…”

“But we’re nerds at heart, right?” notes John, and all three explode into laughter.

Dream Theater posing for a photograph in 2016

Dream Theater’s James LaBrie in 2016 (Image credit: Jimmy Fontaine/Press)

Dream Theater, rounded out by bassist John Myung and drummer Mike Mangini, are fully aware of how they are perceived. Throughout the last 30 years, they’ve managed to become one of metal’s biggest and most consistently successful bands, despite being, by all mainstream standards, desperately uncool.

The cover of Metal Hammer magazine issue 280 featuring Lemmy

This feature originally appeared in Metal Hammer issue 280 (Jan 2016) (Image credit: Future)

This time round, however, the gloves are definitely off. The Astonishing is not just an album: it’s a fully immersive story with its own screenplay, artwork and trading cards. It appears custom-built for future movie or stage show adaptations, not to mention the videogame market and, for maximum nerd points, the fantasy RPG world. It’s as if John Petrucci and his comrades are saying, “So, you thought we were massive nerds? Well check this shit out!”

“Ha ha ha! Yeah, that’s true, I guess. If you thought we were nerdy before, this will blow your mind!” laughs John. “As far as the RPG stuff goes, that would be the least of the influence. It’s not something that I’m personally into, but I think it crosses over in the sense that we’re all into sci-fi and fantasy; we all love Star Wars, Game Of Thrones, Lord Of The Rings, any futuristic stories about the Apocalypse…”

“And even Harry Potter!” grins Jordan.

“Ha ha ha! Yeah, Harry Potter, too. We love all that. So if anything, this grandiose way of looking at things comes more from movies. Whether it’s progressive music as a genre, gaming, sci-fi as a genre… it’s a very similar headspace for all of those. It’s for people that love storytelling and diving into the detail, the methodology of it all.”

“The whole prog movement is about fairies and elves and we’re proud of that!” Jordan cheerily proclaims, before adding, deadpan, “but there are no fairies and elves on this album.”

Instead, The Astonishing takes place in a world where societies have collapsed and been replaced by a feudal system: empires ruled by all-powerful leaders, with ordinary people reduced to cowed worker bees, striving for survival. Like many a sci-fi scenario, the album transports us to a dark and menacing time that is just plausible enough to ring true on some deep level. It certainly helps that some of the story’s principle supporting facts parallel what’s going on around us in 2016.

Dream Theater – The Gift Of Music [OFFICIAL VIDEO] – YouTube Dream Theater - The Gift Of Music [OFFICIAL VIDEO] - YouTube

Watch On

“The world [of The Astonishing] has returned to feudalism, the way it was when the aristocracy had all the money and the land and the power and ordinary people were just toiling,” John explains. “So that’s a little bit of a comment on what’s happening today and where things could potentially go. The other aspect is that in a lot of industries, robots are taking over and replacing humans, and so what would happen if that happened to the arts? In this future, with all this technology, in an effort to make perfect music, we make artificially intelligent machines – the NOMACs – that make music, and there’s no need for humans to make music anymore. So it’s about the juxtaposition of hearing these NOMACS making this really crappy nonsense music, because that’s what they think is good, and then hearing Dream Theater playing, with real strings, a real guitars, a real piano and a real singer…”

One of the more heartening phenomena of recent times has been the quiet but steady backlash against the disposability of much modern music and entertainment. A resurgence of interest in vinyl, box sets and immersive TV series that are consumed in huge, absorbing chunks, suggests that many people are rediscovering the joy of engaging with music and art, rather than merely using it as bland wallpaper to accompany other activities.

“It takes a certain mentality to listen to music,” Jordan states. “You’ve got to have patience or maybe just meditate. Everybody is more and more distracted, everyone’s multitasking… if you’re not looking at a screen, you’re being pulled away from it. It’s harder and harder to focus.”

“Music has definitely become a background for a lot of people,” nods James. “It’s not necessarily something people are listening to, and it could easily be a NOMAC in the background just making sounds while they’re texting their friends. Everyone is so inundated with so much media these days. There are too many distractions, whereas when we were all growing up, it was something to look forward to – you’d go and get that album and you’d sit with it the whole weekend and you’d keep spinning it, because you didn’t have all those distractions. This album is very relevant to that and what we’re seeing happening right now. It could easily go that way, right?”

Dream Theater posing for a photograph in 2016

Dream Theater’s John Petrucci in 2016 (Image credit: Jimmy Fontaine/Press)

“One of the things that we find more and more is that yes, there is a pop culture and yes, there is pop music, but there is a huge community of likeminded people who love to dive into things and want more substance,” adds John. “The people who love Star Wars and the mythology, that’s a huge community. It’s a matter of tapping into that and trying to do something that brings all those elements together. Ourselves as music fans, we’re like that. Dream Theater fans in general are like that. But to combine it, most musicians I talk to, you mention Game Of Thrones and they’re like, ‘Oh my god!’ but it’s the same headspace, you know? And so we’re trying to bring it all together.”

The great irony of Dream Theater’s approach to making music has never been more obvious. As The Astonishing combines elements that Game Of Thrones, Star Wars, Lord Of The Rings and even World Of Warcraft people will recognise, it should exert an allure beyond anything the band have achieved. But prog metal of this particular hue is routinely sneered at by some music fans, as if one kind of flat-out nerdiness is acceptable, but another is beyond the pale. Luckily, Dream Theater don’t particularly care and, more importantly, they are in this for the long haul.

The release of The Astonishing is just the beginning: as people start to explore the band’s newly minted future world and dive into the vivid intricacies of music and narrative, the first of a series of intimate live shows, where the album will be performed in its mind-bending entirety, will be taking place in London on February 18. It will be augmented with a full movie presentation; a grand, extra layer of experiential substance.

Dream Theater – Our New World [OFFICIAL VIDEO] – YouTube Dream Theater – Our New World [OFFICIAL VIDEO] - YouTube

Watch On

“We have a lot of special things planned, if they all happen!” John beams. “Besides our lighting engineer and set designer, we have another group of people in Montreal who specialise in this kind of immersive stage experience, a transformative experience using video, so it’ll be a combination of a physical set and video panels. It will almost be like a full movie that we’ll play along with. So you get your popcorn and you find your seat, and then you’re listening to us play and watching this visual experience at the same time. It should be fun! We have high expectations, so I hope we pull it off, ha ha ha!”

“People have become disconnected,” notes James. “I guess we need to help to re-educate people – that it’s OK to sit down with one thing and immerse yourself in it. It’s one of the great joys in life.”

Inspired by an honest love for the creation of extraordinary music and the telling of extraordinary tales, The Astonishing may not convert many nonbelievers, but Dream Theater can hardly be accused of not putting the effort in. Yes, The Astonishing is preposterous. But if you’re willing to give it a try, it might just blow your mind.

“You know what? We know we’re asking a lot!” John laughs. “We really are. It’s one thing to say, ‘Check out this 20-minute song!’ because fortunately we have a lot of people who like that kind of thing. But, ‘Put aside a couple of hours to listen to this album’? Ha ha! We romanticise the idea that people will sit down like they’re watching a movie and enjoy the whole thing from beginning to end, but we keep laughing about it, too, like, ‘Hey dude, have you heard the new Dream Theater album?’ ‘No, dude, but I’ve set Saturday aside…’ Ha ha ha!”

Originally published in Metal Hammer issue 280, January 2016

Dom Lawson has been writing for Metal Hammer and Prog for over 14 years and is extremely fond of heavy metal, progressive rock, coffee and snooker. He also contributes to The Guardian, Classic Rock, Bravewords and Blabbermouth and has previously written for Kerrang! magazine in the mid-2000s.